The Lime Inn is a bit of a St John institution. Long owned by founders Rich (the long time maitre ‘d) and his wife Chris, they have now passed on the 32 year tradition to their daughter Chelsea and her husband Richard. They continue to serve up some of the best fish and key lime pie on the island. We especially love their ‘all you can eat shrimp’ night — messy but oh so good! Lobsters every night and an ‘all day’ happy hour will surely please. They are conveniently located in the heart of Cruz Bay.